URL has been copied successfully!

The seven pitfalls of self-organization

by Erik Bouwer

The seven pitfalls of self-organization

by Erik Bouwer

by Erik Bouwer
URL has been copied successfully!

Self-organization is not an end in itself, but a means to achieve another goal. It is therefore logical that self-organization is never 'finished'. That is why it is not obvious to regard self-organization as something that you as a manager simply 'implement'. Professor Mandy van der Velde therefore regards the implementation of self-organization as 'organizational change' – a process that takes years rather than months before it is fully completed.

 

What are the motives for getting started with self-organization? In the first place, organizations can use it to increase their attractiveness as an employer by tapping into the work preferences of younger generations. You can also work on better employee satisfaction along the way of self-organization. Self-organization can also contribute to the effectiveness of (parts of) the organization. By placing decisions low in the organization you can steer faster (regulation capacity where it belongs) and save on management and staff functions. This is becoming increasingly important because changes in the environment are occurring at a faster pace. And finally, with self-organization you can give more space to cooperation, creativity and initiative, things that are increasingly needed to solve problems. Think of fast and ad hoc collaboration with internal or external specialists, short meetings during the day (standups) or conducting short experiments.

Autonomy is not, but job satisfaction is important for everyone

Mandy van der Velde (including Endowed Professor of Management of Change Processes in Large Organizations at Utrecht University and VU Amsterdam, and affiliated with Coniche Business School (formerly School for Customer Management): “The focus on self-management and self-organization has been going up and down for decades. It has been in the spotlight in the healthcare sector for a number of years, but now the critical voices are increasing again. The financial sector is also looking for the effects of self-organizing teams. I consider self-organization as a cautious start to get people into organizations to be more involved.”

Researchers Hackman and Oldman (see box) have shown that autonomy is one of the task characteristics that determines the motivation to do a task. Van der Velde explains: “Self-organization encourages people to take responsibility, for example by making decisions themselves. The question is, of course, whether a task characteristic such as autonomy is equally important for everyone. In addition, self-organization is not applicable in every process – think of environments where protocols are leading. But the way things are going now in customer contact, I don't think it works. Companies still make too little use of scientifically proven relationships between, for example, job characteristics, performance and job satisfaction or job satisfaction.”

Job characteristics model by Hackman and Oldman (1980)
The program job-characteristics model assumes five task characteristics, which can lead to three types of psychological 'states' that determine the degree to which someone is motivated.

Those job characteristics are skill variety (the extent to which a job requires different activities in performing the tasks, using different skills and talents of the worker); job identity (the extent to which the job requires a complete process or product), job importance (the extent to which the job impacts the lives of other people inside or outside the organization), autonomy (the extent to which an employee can work autonomously and independently) and feedback (information about the effectiveness of their performance contributes to motivation).

These five characteristics determine the perceived meaningfulness of the work, the perceived sense of responsibility and the extent to which the employee is well informed about the effectiveness of performance. The sum of all this in turn determines the performance, motivation and satisfaction of the employee.

 

Self-organization requires space and trust

When increasing self-organizing capacity, giving confidence and offering room to make mistakes are paramount, according to Van der Velde. “It doesn't help if managers are directed from above primarily on figures or turnover. You can also achieve those goals in a different way.” In other words, making the transition to self-organization has consequences for individual employees and for individual managers. “If people really don't want to, they leave. People have different needs. There are also different types of employees in a contact center,” says Van der Velde. “A student with a part-time job may look at his or her job differently than someone who supports a family. But in the end, I think most people will be happier if they can make their own choices, also at work. The behavior of the manager is the success factor.”

 

Misunderstandings about self-management
Self-management and self-organization are not the same thing. Self-steering literally means that the team directs itself. In this way, the team also determines the direction of the activities. It therefore involves strategic questions, such as: what goals do we want to achieve when and what ratio between costs and revenues do we consider acceptable. Self-organization is usually limited to the route that the team can choose itself. Time frames, budget and goals are provided by management as frameworks. However, the team can decide for itself how priorities are determined and who fulfills which roles. The team also has a responsibility to stay within the set frameworks.

 

The seven pitfalls of self-organization

1. What mag you and what must is? – the key question for every position within an organization. In the world of customer contact, the relationship between responsibilities and authorities is often still a difficult subject. You have to achieve a certain level of productivity, but you can't decide on everything. When you introduce self-organization, you choose to broaden the mandate of the team – and of the team members. What can the team decide on? Strategy? Budget? Human resources? Schedule? How does self-rostering fit into self-organization? Who makes which decisions and how? Talking about the mandate is not possible without a discussion about accountability.

2. Who monitors the overview? Teams can also be too preoccupied with themselves. Outward looking and contact with other teams is crucial – for example, to prevent team goals from getting in each other's way. Or to avoid individual teams reinventing the wheel. Or that standardization will get in the way. Guidance is often needed not only to maintain coordination and cooperation with other teams, but also to keep the momentum going. Is the organization prepared to attract new people from outside for this?

3. As teams get bigger, the need for coordination increases. Coordination is also necessary when a crisis breaks out. For example, if you need to scale up faster or scale down strongly. Delegating a reorganization to a self-organizing team is then a bit difficult. The question is therefore whether self-organization is appropriate in every situation. You have to think about future scenarios in advance.

4. 'Introducing' self-organization is a long process. It leads to all kinds of changes in the organization. Managers will have different roles and will have to let go of old habits. Employees have to learn new things, for example taking the initiative and actively learning from mistakes. For self-organization to succeed, teams need management information. Are departments willing to share it? Do teams get the right authorizations in systems? A coach is often needed to guide the existing organization and the teams-to-be on these points. Time is also needed to arrange matters at the back of the organization. Think about rethinking information security.

5. Attention, connection problems. Not everything changes. Such is often the environment of a new self-organizing team (internal and external). NOT ALLOWED self-organizing. Other departments simply keep their own KPIs, management layers and lead times. The support (HR, ICT, quality) is also often not geared to working with self-organizing teams. There is a high chance of new bottlenecks, because standard procedures no longer suffice – think of reward and assessment. Staff departments therefore have to deal with two types of teams. Or with different types of KPIs that are not always in line with each other.

6. Self-organization is not just fun. Teams get a different dynamic, because discussing and deciding on the working method becomes a larger part of the work. Dividing up tasks also means that someone has to do the tedious chores. And that more mistakes and new mistakes are made. Meanwhile watch the surroundings: when does it go wrong? Team members become more dependent on each other than on the manager. That requires a bigger one confidence: within the team, but also outside the team.

7. The way back is painful. Introducing self-organization requires letting go and giving trust. Managers must continue to give space, even if the performance of teams temporarily declines. 'Backwards planning' can therefore do no harm: think in advance about the end goal and what you might encounter along the way. For example, dismissal or transfer of managers who cannot let go. Thinking in advance about accepting adverse impact can also help. It to wind back of self-organization – for example because teams are structurally bogged down or lack support – can be seen as the ultimate sign of distrust: teams have failed to organize themselves. The departure of the best employees who do not want to go back to the old situation can be the result.

 

PlanMen is organizing the PlanMen WFM Congress on 19 and 20 September. Self-organization is one of the themes that will be discussed there. Read more.

Also read: Does self-organization suit the contact center?

Interesting article? Share it!
RSS
Follow by Email
Whatsapp
LinkedIn
Copy link

Also interesting

Featured, Human Resources, Knowledge base , ,
Top